Chumby vs. iPhone

Julie let me play with her Chumby. Chumby start up What’s a Chumby? Well, a Chumby is a little dream machine. A wifi, linux-based widget bean bag with a touch screen and speakers. It is a technology nexus a little ahead of its time. I say ahead of its time because it’s also not quite there yet. Here’s my review: Chumby clockEveryone on the Interaction Design team is aware of the Chumby. We were interested in the possibilities of such a device. But there were a lot of delays getting this thing into the world. The beta nature of the product is showing. It is trying to bridge a lot of technologies to give you what is perhaps just a fancy alarm clock. bad_bunny.jpgIt has a little button in its plush top, perhaps for hitting the inevitable snooze. The set up is via the chumby web site. You set up a channel of widgets that then cycle. On the chumby itself, you select the channel you want to display and off it goes. Chumby Google newsFirst impressions: It’s small. Smaller than I thought and perhaps smaller than it needs to be. It’s screen is tiny. You need to be sitting near it. Also, the power cord. You really want something like this to be rechargeable. A pet you can carry with you, set on your desk maybe. Seeing RSS feeds on a Chumby begins to suggest how cool this could be. It’s cute. It’s helpful. Chumby deathSo I poked around in it’s plush pouch and found a connection for a nine-volt. I plugged one in and everything worked fine for a cycle of the channel and then Chumby death. I also noticed that the screen was getting a little warm around the edges. Stuffing a nine volt into a plush little computer is odd enough, but then it getting hot is a bit scary. After powering off and reinserting the power cord, things were running smooth again. Chumby backUSB memory sticks are not sexy sticking out of the back of your Chumby. Neither are the variety of cords. The Chumby has speakers and you can plug an iPod into the USB port on the back. Through the really stripped down music interface, you can shuffle or play a playlist. Sitting with an iPod Nano plugged into the Chumby, starts to beg the question: Why am I jumping through these hoops to get a little iPod boombox with a little touch screen interface that kind of works (my fat fingers were wrestling to make it go). So has Apple already made the Chumby a moot point with its iPod Touch and iPhone? It’s hard to say. If you weigh the benefits of the open architecture and the little speakers, the USB connections, etc. I suppose you could make a case for the Chumby being a worthy accessory. But immediately, I felt like all these cables, the reduced usability of the interface, and the price, make the iPhone or iPod Touch a much cooler offering. Did I mention that the Chumby is $200? Cheaper than an iPhone, sure. But it won’t fit in your pocket. The culture of the Chumby encourages customization. For the tinkerer, it has a lot of interesting possibilities. The Chumby is a cool hack. It is a grab bag of all the things we tech-geeks dream of in a gadget. But for Joe Consumer looking to get his RSS feeds from the back porch while reading a book, you probably want what Apple offers. We’re looking at the developer’s puzzle of implementing widgets for this device and other Flash Lite devices to come (including the iPhone which doesn’t support Flash yet. C’mon Apple and Adobe, hurry it up!). The Chumby site provides a gallery of widgets to choose from if you are not tech-savvy to that degree. Ryan had the bright idea of building little spider legs for the thing so it can run around on its own power. That gets at what these sorts of devices aspire to: a little helper bot. Roomba meet Chumby. [youtube mj4lsNw3IG0]
Chumby vs. iPhone
Scott Krieger
Senior Developer/Strategist
Scott stays at the front of our technology evolution, pushing us and easing our clients along to ever more elegant, agile expressions of information. He's a genius.

Comments

Here’s a Chumby 9 volt discussion: http://forum.chumby.com/viewtopic.php?pid=5575 Building low power consumption devices is hard (and necessary). My big complaint about the chumby I saw was that because it needed external power it was effictively tethered, and thus couldn’t be tossed around like the plush toy it looked it. If dig into the net.history you should look at the saga of Pointcast, which is basically “Chumby for your laptop” - same architecture of broadcasting applications to your machine to run on a schedule.
I’m thankful the iPhone doesn’t support flash. I wish more web viewers didn’t support flash. There is nothing more annoying that visiting a site build completely on flash. After waiting 10 minutes for the site to load you realize that if there is any valuable information on the site, you can’t forward it to a friend or tell them to take a look at a certain page. Search engines don’t like flash either, which then begs the question… Why is flash still being used? Perhaps, in reality, it isn’t. Anytime my browsing lands me on a flash based webpage, I can’t seem to hit the “back” button fast enough. I hold my glass high to the death of the flash based website.
But you have to admit, Krieger, that as USB memory sticks go, my transparent purple mini one is, actually, pretty sexy.
I spent some time thinking about this Chumby vs. iPhone and realized an important distinction: the iPhone is a personal interface to the internet. The Chumby is actually better positioned as an avatar or output device. If you have one sitting on your desk, it can display a Twitter feed or some other manifestation of your days activity. Someone looking for you finds your Chumby which can communicate where you are, what you are doing etc. No more fumbling around to find your team mates. Instead, they are perhaps using the iPhone to keep their Chumby up to date. The Chumby can communicate with personality all those actions. You can even have it displaying your tracklist if you are listening to music. Photos, etc. Just one more tool in the arsenal.
These pictures don’t really show Chumby’s scale either, so I submit the following link: http://www.chumby.com/story I also encourage people to take a look at the friends of chumby flickr page too: http://www.flickr.com/photos/11410414@N06/ and the Chumby Industries flickr page too: http://www.flickr.com/photos/33515138@N00/999629545/in/photostream/ Thank you for the review Scott, and thanks for bringing in your Chumby Julie.